Is One-Size-Fits-All Pricing a Thing of the Past? At look at the strategy of Pricing of consulting.

Learn how to create pricing structures that accurately reflect the value of your services and cater to diverse client requirements, guaranteeing long-term business success. Discover sustainable pricing strategies.

We've all been there. You're working with a potential new consulting client, exploring how you can help solve their challenges, deliver meaningful results, and drive their business forward. Things are going well – there's good chemistry, the client seems bought into your approach and expertise. And then the dreaded question comes:

"So what do you charge for this?"

Suddenly, the conversation shifts from the client's needs and the value you can provide to an uncomfortable dance around dollars and cents. If you're not fully confident in your pricing, you may find yourself stumbling through a vague answer, offering a broad range, or worse, resorting to "it depends…"

The firms that are most successful over the long run have a well-defined pricing strategy and structure that accomplishes three key objectives:

  1. It reflects the full value of the services they provide
  2. It accommodates different client needs and situations
  3. It ensures the overall sustainability and profitability of their business

So how do you develop a pricing strategy that ticks all of these boxes? Through our work, we've identified several best practices that the top consulting firms get right when it comes to pricing their services. Let's dive in.

Start With Your Value Proposition
Before you even think about pricing, you need to have crystal clear clarity on the value you deliver to clients. What specific problems do you solve? How are your services and expertise uniquely positioned to address those issues? What tangible results and benefits do clients receive by working with you?

This might sound like marketing 101, but it's crucial for grounding your pricing in the value you provide, not just the costs you incur or the hours you put in. The most successful firms we work with have honed their value proposition to a sharp point. They know their ideal client profile, the issues that keep those buyers up at night, and how their services are tailored to deliver results.

For example, let's imagine a boutique consulting firm focused exclusively on helping medium-sized manufacturing companies improve operational efficiency and throughput. Their whole business is oriented around their ability to identify process bottlenecks, optimize the shop floor, reduce material waste, and quantify the resulting productivity gains and cost savings.

Because their value proposition is so concrete, it's much easier for them to have productive pricing conversations with prospective clients. They can articulate a clear ROI based on prior client results. The buyer understands exactly what they're paying for and the results they can expect. It shifts the context from cost to investment, inputs to outcomes.

So before you build out your pricing structure, pressure test your value proposition. How clearly and specifically can you articulate the value you deliver? What proof points and client examples can you provide to illustrate your impact? If you can't have that conversation with confidence, keep refining your focus and approach until you can.

Understand Your Costs and Margins
With a solid handle on your value proposition, you're ready to look inward at the economics of your business. What are the costs and inputs required to deliver your services? This includes both the direct costs associated with each engagement as well as your organisational overhead – things like office space, support staff, tools and technology, marketing expenses, etc.

You'll want to build a solid financial model that accounts for all of these costs and helps you understand the gross margins for your different services at various price points and engagement sizes. The key is to identify a pricing range that allows for a healthy, sustainable margin while still being competitive in your market.

Many firms make the mistake of defaulting to an hourly or daily rate based on direct costs and a simple markup formula. But this misses the larger picture. Your price shouldn't just be based on short-term profit on a particular project. It needs to account for the long-term sustainability and growth of your overall practice.

Provide Options and Customization
One of the biggest pricing challenges many consulting firms face is how to create standardized pricing while still accommodating diverse client needs and budgets. No two clients or projects are the same, so you need some flexibility. But you also can't afford to start from scratch with every proposal and spend hours on custom pricing.

The best approach we've found is to provide a menu of options – a set of pre-defined service packages and price points that clients can choose from and customize as needed. This allows you to simplify your pricing conversations and proposals while still providing clients with the ability to tailor a solution to their unique situation.

Most of our clients structure their pricing options in tiers, with escalating levels of service and price. A basic tier might include a limited scope of work and a more templated approach. As the price increases, so does the depth of the engagement – more senior staff, more creativity and customisation, more on-site time, more implementation support, etc.

Here's an example of pricing tiers:

Tier 1 – "Spark"

  • Limited scope, focused on ideation and concept development
  • Deliverables include research insights, brainstorming sessions, and high-level concepting
  • Staffed primarily by junior designers
  • Fixed fee based on project duration (2-4 weeks)

Tier 2 – "Ignite"

  • Includes everything in Spark, plus prototyping and user testing
  • Deliverables also include refined concepts, prototypes, and user feedback reports
  • Staffed by mid-level and senior designers
  • Fixed fee based on project duration (6-8 weeks)

Tier 3 – "Blaze"

  • Soup-to-nuts design program
  • Includes everything in Ignite, plus product roadmap, detailed design, and launch support
  • Staffed by senior designers and firm leadership
  • Customized pricing based on project scope and duration

This approach gives clients clear options and price expectations while also leaving room for tailoring based on project specifics. And it makes for a much more productive pricing conversation. Instead of spending time justifying your hourly rate or haggling over line items, you can focus on which service package provides the right level of depth and support for the client's needs and budget.

Consider Alternative Pricing Models
While fixed-fee, service-based pricing is the norm for most consulting engagements, don't be afraid to explore alternative approaches that may be a better fit for certain offerings or client situations. The key is to find a model that shares risk and reward and aligns your incentives with the client's.

Performance-based pricing is one option that's gaining traction in some consulting sectors. In this model, some or all of your fees are contingent on the results you deliver. If you're able to quantify the expected outcomes and ROI of the engagement, you can define a bonus or kicker based on exceeding those targets. This approach shows that you're willing to put some skin in the game and bet on your ability to drive results.

We've seen this used most often by firms that focus on boosting marketing and sales performance, where outcomes are more easily measurable. For instance, a sales training consultancy might charge a base fee for the initial training and kickoff, with an additional percentage of revenue earned from the new sales process over the first year. Or a digital marketing agency might get a bonus for leads or sales beyond the forecast ROI.

Another alternative is value-based pricing, where you work with the client to define the expected economic impact and value of the project, then set your price as a percentage of that value. This requires a willingness and ability to have a frank discussion about the client's finances and expected ROI. But it can yield a much higher price point and margin if you're confident in the value you can deliver.

Subscriptions and retainers are another model to consider, especially for ongoing services or long-term client relationships. Instead of pricing each engagement, you provide access to a certain level of service for a recurring monthly or annual fee. This provides more of an annuity-based revenue stream for your firm while giving clients predictable costs and support.

The right pricing model will depend on the specifics of your business and client base. But don't default to the standard approach of hourly or project-based fees without considering other options. The most successful firms we work with are always exploring alternative models that better reflect the value they provide and align their incentives with client outcomes.

Put It All Together
We've covered a lot of ground in this article, so let's recap the key takeaways:

  1. Ground your pricing in a clearly defined value proposition that specifies the concrete results and benefits clients can expect.

  2. Develop a comprehensive financial model that accounts for all of your costs and sets sustainable margin targets.

  3. Provide multiple service tiers and options to accommodate different client needs and budgets while still simplifying your pricing approach.

  1. Consider alternative pricing models like performance-based, value-based, or subscription pricing for the right opportunities.

  2. Continuously refine and adjust your pricing strategy as you gather data and feedback from the market.

Remember, a strategic pricing approach isn't just about maximizing short-term revenue. It's about defining and capturing the full value of your expertise and services in a way that's fair to clients and supports a thriving, profitable, and sustainable consulting practice for the long run.


Other Trending Articles

Discover the changing landscape of tabletop exercising and gaming with LGP. Gain insights into the growing demand for risk simulation, collaborative team building, and soft skills training. Learn how organizations are leveraging tabletop exercises to practice decision-making and build valuable skills. Follow LGP for more interactive and immersive learning insights.

The Changing Landscape of Tabletop Exercising: Insights from the LGP Team

Discover the changing landscape of tabletop exercising and gaming with LGP. Gain insights into the growing demand for risk simulation, collaborative team building, and soft skills training. Learn how organizations are leveraging tabletop exercises to practice decision-making and build valuable skills. Follow LGP for more interactive and immersive learning insights.